Logos On Aid Supplies: Useful, Demeaning … Or Harmful?

Enlarge this imageA Palestinian girl and her little ones obtain supplies through the Worldwide Committee of the Pink Cro s at a refugee camp in Gaza; a latrine task in Haiti financed by Oxfam; a UNICEF tent at a refugee camp in Iraq.Abid Katib/Getty Visuals; Jonathan Torgovnik/Getty Pictures; Florian Gaertner/Photothek through Getty Imageshide captiontoggle captionAbid Katib/Getty Pictures; Jonathan Torgovnik/Getty Images; Florian Gaertner/Photothek via Getty ImagesA Palestinian girl and her children receive supplies from the Intercontinental Committee in the Purple Cro s in a refugee camp in Gaza; a latrine task in Haiti financed by Oxfam; a UNICEF tent at a refugee camp in Iraq.Abid Katib/Getty Photographs; Jonathan Torgovnik/Getty Photos; Florian Gaertner/Photothek by using Getty ImagesIt looks just like a really easy point. Each time a humanitarian team arms out baggage of foods or sets up toilets for those who are weak or recovering from the crisis, the group puts its logo over the product. It is a way of taking credit, which makes donors joyful. It is really a means of allowing the recipients know wherever to complain if you will find a problem. And when you happen to be sitting down in the home and catch the emblem with a Television report, you might be Alex Bregman Jersey encouraged to lead to that exact charity. But now, some people are questioning the branding of aid merchandise. The primary problem: How do the logos make aid recipients truly feel? Ian Birrell, a world reporter along with a contributing editor to Good Britain's The Mail on Sunday, tweeted an image of a corrugated latrine doorway from the excursion on the Bidi Bidi refugee camp in Uganda in Could. Oversize indicators for that U.K.'s Office for Intercontinental Development and UNICEF, the U.N. children's agency, take up almost half from the door.Birrell wrote, "So demeaning for people who fled chaos and carnage for being endle sly reminded in their supplicant standing." In some Ugandan refugee settlements, each rest room has these stickers on them. So demeaning for individuals who fled chaos & carnage to become endle sly reminded of their supplicant standing pic.twitter.com/szy50L7oJ5 Ian Birrell (@ianbirrell) June 3, 2018 Sudhanshu S. Singh, CEO of an India-based emergency relief group called Humanitarian A sist Worldwide, agrees. Singh recalls a time any time a major relief group provided plastic water buckets for aid recipients with its emblem emblazoned on each pail in huge letters. "I think it truly is unfair as each time individuals choose out the bucket to fetch water, others would immediately notice that it is part with the dole," he says. Singh doesn't want to do away with logos completely. "Some visibility is required to the sake of accountability, but it should not look like an advertisement or self-glorification, which is against the dignity with the persons," he says. Big players in aid like UNICEF, for example, say that it does just that. In a statement to NPR, UNICEF spokesperson Joe English said: "As an organization, we are committed to upholding the dignity of each and every child and adult that we support." And some recipients Andy Pettitte Jersey don't mind the logos. Cedric Habiyaremye, a Rwandan Ph.D. student at Washington State University, remembers when he was living in a refugee camp in Tanzania as an 8-year-old. Each day, he would see trucks labeled "WFP" short for World Foodstuff Programme, the U.N. meals agency come into the camp.Goats and Soda This Farmer Wants To Make Quinoa A 'Thing' In Rwanda "As kids we didn't call it 'WFP.' We called it wefpe. And we'd start singing, 'Wefpe, wefpe!' when we saw the trucks. We were full of joy, because we knew we were going to eat at that time," he says. "It was a very rea suring time of day." Habiyaremye says he used to peel the WFP labels off bottles of cooking oil to decorate his toys. "No one complained that the logos were demeaning or humiliating," he says. "I feel that I am glad I got to know who served me at the refugee camp." And that kind of connection is what aid groups want on a global scale. Research has shown that there is a relationship between a brand's visibility its public recognition and donations, says Dmitry Chernobrov, a lecturer in journalism and politics at the University of Sheffield. "When agencies post these logos on toilets, schools, objects, it is very much about gaining visibility to donor audiences through the intercontinental media," he says. These logos also help ensure that charities and donors get credit rating for their good deeds. According to USAID's branding guide, their pink, white and blue brand "was developed to ensure that the American men and women are visibly acknowledged for their contributions." Logos have become such a powerful tool that there have been incidents of ISIS stealing U.N. food aid, slapping their own logo around the boxes and redistributing it back to folks. Governments especially individuals recovering from the humanitarian crisis are anxious to get credit, too, says W. Gyude Moore, the former Liberian minister of public works. Except there's one trouble: They don't often control the purse strings. After the Ebola epidemic, foreign governments and help groups came to Liberia to help the country finance big infrastructure projects. It was Moore's job as part of your Liberian government to negotiate these public works contracts. And signage boasting the flags and logos of task donors the U.N., the EU, the African Improvement Bank, the World Bank, USAID became commonplace. Moore recalls Roy Oswalt Jersey a individual sign off the side of the road in a rural part of Liberia: "A big, blue EU sign with the yellow stars that says, 'This maintenance was paid for by the EU and the U.K. government' in addition to a small Liberian flag in the corner." The signage got so out of hand that Moore would joke: "Why don't we paint the asphalt road with your country's flag, too?"Goats and Soda Local Support Groups Are Key To Disaster Relief. So Why Are They Overlooked? There's a danger to this over-branding, says Moore. "What's the role in the state if it is unable to provide the most basic services for its people today?" he says. It's the topic of a new paper he's written for your think tank Center for Global Improvement, where he is now a visiting fellow. He argues that in fragile states, it truly is in the best interests of aid groups and improvement agencies to let the property country get credit for big-ticket a sist interventions and rebuilding efforts even if their role was to negotiate the deal. After crises, governments and its citizens have a fractured relationship, says Moore. Citizens want to trust that their governments can handle a big shock. And governments want to ensure that they have the trust with the men and women. "Public items like roads, hospitals and schools are the most significant ways the state can make its benevolent presence felt," he writes. Otherwise, it may po sibly lead to "nationwide consequences, ranging from protests to separatism." Meanwhile, concerns about safety have made some aid groups rethink the use of logos. In a conflict zone, when logos are emblazoned on products as well as T-shirts worn by staff, that could put staff at risk. Support workers are increasingly under attack, especially in conflict zones like Syria and Yemen. "[We used to think that] if we stick [a emblem on], everyone will know we're here to do good," says Paul O'Brien, vice president of policy and advocacy at Oxfam America. "But there's le s and le s of that notion that the branding will keep you safe. We need to get out of the branding game." Even as the debate goes on, Habiyaremye for one has no complaints. He got a chance to visit World Meals Programme in Washington, D.C., in 2015 after he won a global agriculture award. He was so excited to meet some from the staff. "I'd been waiting for this moment for my entire life," he says he told them. "I just wanted to tell them thank you."Goats and Soda Can Attacks On A sist Workers Be Stopped?

Posted in DATAPROJEKTOR.

Napsat komentář

Vaše emailová adresa nebude zveřejněna. Vyžadované informace jsou označeny *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.